42nd Annual Quest for Quality Awards Third-party Logistics (3PL)

3PL innovators set the standard for top service


If there’s one segment of the logistics market that’s leveraged the current turmoil as an accelerator for innovation it’s clearly third-party logistics (3PL) providers.

Our reporting over the past year has shown that 3PLs have shown remarkable adaptability, with many providers reworking operations in warehousing, freight transportation, and value-added services to stay competitive and help shippers figure out a way forward—be it with the roiling currents of global trade or setting up e-commerce fulfillment operations here in the U.S.

And while the collective 3PL market took a sizeable revenue hit over 2023 and 2024, the persistence and hard work appears to be paying off. Even through this topsy-turvy economy, Armstrong & Associates projects that the 3PL sector is still poised for growth, with projections indicating a 4.5% increase in gross revenue in 2025.

“There’s little doubt that technology implementation and innovation are key factors enabling 3PLs to remain resilient and grow,” says contributing editor Karen Theurmer, who’s been covering the 3PL market for LM over the past three years. “Many companies are turning to automation, AI, and IoT to enhance operational efficiency and streamline service offerings—especially for shippers looking to leverage 3PLs to grow their e-commerce.

And as e-commerce continues to reshape consumer expectations, 3PLs are playing a critical role in helping shippers meet the growing demands for faster, more efficient fulfillment. “By offering advanced warehousing solutions, omnichannel distribution, and last-mile delivery services, 3PLs are enabling businesses to scale their e-commerce operations effectively,” adds Theurmer.

And while revenue forecasts are starting to tick back up, the 44 3PLs picking up Quest for Quality gold in 2025 can rest assured that their investment in innovation has already paid off. In fact, this year marks a new record of winners in the 3PL category since we separated the market into two distinct areas with the help of Armstrong & Associates—Transportation Management and Value-Added Services.

In our Transportation Management category this year, an impressive 28 3PLs are hanging awards. While all scored above the weighted average, Saddle Creek Logistics Services (56.79), AIT Worldwide Logistics (56.76), and NFI Logistics (56.28) put up the top three overall weighted scores this year. In the 2025 Value-Added category, 16 providers are taking home Quest for Quality awards, with Averitt putting up the top mark with an impressive 56.99 overall weighted score.

Third-Party Logistics Companies: Transportation Management (Bold indicates leader in attribute category)

  Carrier selection/negotiation Order fulfillment Transportation distribution Inventory management Logistics information systems Weighted score
Saddle Creek Logistics Services 10.30 11.00 11.37 10.25 11.87 56.79
AIT Worldwide Logistics 10.98 11.85 11.25 10.82 11.87 56.76
NFI Logistics 11.75 11.25 11.60 10.55 11.13 56.28
Penske Logistics 10.17 12.38 12.76 10.55 10.01 55.87
UPS Supply Chain Solutions 10.85 10.80 11.60 10.55 11.57 55.37
DB Schenker Americas 10.55 12.00 12.37 9.85 10.38 55.15
Americold 10.33 11.25 12.76 9.50 11.13 54.96
Matson Logistics 9.94 11.25 11.60 10.55 11.13 54.47
DHL Supply Chain 10.55 11.70 12.06 10.13 9.79 54.23
CEVA Logistics 12.27 12.00 10.83 9.85 8.90 53.84
Allen Lund Company 9.04 11.25 11.60 10.55 11.13 53.57
Armstrong Transport Group 9.04 11.25 11.60 10.55 11.13 53.57
J.B. Hunt Transport Services 11.82 10.13 11.27 9.65 10.57 53.43
C.H. Robinson Worldwide 9.89 11.05 11.60 9.71 10.52 52.76
FedEx Supply Chain 10.25 10.64 11.14 10.32 10.11 52.45
Schneider Logistics 10.17 10.13 10.83 11.25 10.01 52.39
Odyssey Logistics 9.04 11.25 11.60 8.44 11.13 51.46
Kuehne + Nagel 10.85 11.25 11.60 8.44 8.90 51.04
APL Logistics 10.55 10.50 12.37 7.03 10.38 50.84
Werner Enterprises 10.33 9.00 10.44 9.50 11.13 50.39
Crane Worldwide Logistics 9.94 11.25 9.28 8.44 11.13 50.04
Maersk Logistics 10.55 10.50 10.05 9.14 9.64 49.89
AFS Logistics 7.91 10.50 11.60 8.44 11.13 49.58
American Fast Freight, A subsidiary of Odyssey Logistics & Technology 9.04 11.25 11.60 8.44 8.90 49.23
TForce Worldwide (RR Donnelley/DLS Worldwide) 10.55 10.50 10.83 8.44 8.90 49.21
Landstar 9.04 7.50 11.60 10.55 10.38 49.07
Knight-Swift Transportation 10.17 9.90 10.44 8.73 9.79 49.03
Trailer Bridge 8.82 11.25 11.60 8.44 8.90 49.01
AVERAGE 9.40 10.19 10.51 9.14 9.75 48.99

Third-Party Logistics Companies: Value Added Services (Bold indicates leader in attribute category)

  Customer service/Value added services Order fulfillment Transportation distribution Inventory management Logistics information systems Weighted score
Averitt 11.68 10.79 11.08 11.71 11.73 56.99
Saddle Creek Logistic Services 11.51 10.49 11.78 11.41 11.44 56.63
Penske Logistics 10.38 11.49 11.68 11.41 11.44 56.41
CEVA Logistics 11.45 11.05 11.33 10.98 11.00 55.80
NFI 10.68 11.05 11.33 10.98 11.00 55.03
FedEx Supply Chain 10.99 10.45 11.78 10.85 10.40 54.46
GXO Logistics (formerly XPO) 11.68 10.31 11.88 10.24 10.27 54.58
Lineage Logistics 10.67 11.49 10.87 10.54 10.56 54.13
DHL Supply Chain 12.45 10.31 10.57 10.24 10.27 53.85
Maersk Logistics 11.93 10.73 11.00 10.03 10.06 53.76
UPS Supply Chain Solutions 11.21 10.17 11.07 10.24 11.00 53.69
Wagner Logistics 9.34 11.05 11.33 10.98 11.00 53.69
Kuehne + Nagel 11.34 11.05 11.33 9.88 9.90 53.49
DSV A/S 11.21 11.05 11.33 8.78 11.00 53.36
Ryder System, Inc. 11.09 8.84 10.19 10.98 11.73 52.83
Weber Logistics 11.68 11.05 9.06 8.78 11.00 51.57
AVERAGE 10.36 9.99 10.37 9.94 9.92 50.59

Article Topics

Magazine Archive
Logistics
3PL
3PLs
AIT Worldwide Logistics
Averitt
NFI Logistics
Quest for Quality
Saddle Creek Logistics Services
Service Excellence
   All topics

AIT Worldwide Logistics News & Resources

42nd Annual Quest for Quality Awards Third-party Logistics (3PL)
EU Update 2024: Crises lead to growth
AIT Worldwide Logistics opens up new L.A.-based West Coast headquarters

Latest in Logistics

FTR’s Shippers Conditions Index shows modest growth
Trucking executives are set to anxiously welcome in New Year amid uncertainty regarding freight demand
ASCM’s top 10 supply chain trends highlight a year of intelligent transformation
Tariffs continue to cast a long shadow over freight markets heading into 2026
U.S.-bound imports see November declines, reports S&P Global Market Intelligence
FTR Trucking Conditions Index shows slight gain while remaining short of growth
AAR reports mixed U.S. carload and intermodal volumes, for week ending December 6
More Logistics

Subscribe to Logistics Management Magazine

Subscribe today!
Not a subscriber? Sign up today!
Subscribe today. It's FREE.
Find out what the world's most innovative companies are doing to improve productivity in their plants and distribution centers.
Start your FREE subscription today.

December 2025 Logistics Management

December 1, 2025 · Persistent volatility, policy whiplash, and uneven demand left logistics managers feeling trapped in a loop - where every solution seemed temporary, and every forecast came with an asterisk. From tariffs and trucking to rail and ocean freight, the year's defining force was disruption itself

Latest Resources

The Warehouse Efficiency Playbook
Warehouse leaders are under pressure to move faster, scale smarter, and keep teams engaged, all while dealing with labor shortages and rising customer expectations.
Drive Agility and Resilience Across Your Supply Chain
November Edge Report: What’s shaping freight now
More resources

Latest Resources

The Warehouse Efficiency Playbook
The Warehouse Efficiency Playbook
Warehouse leaders are under pressure to move faster, scale smarter, and keep teams engaged, all while dealing with labor shortages and rising...
Drive Agility and Resilience Across Your Supply Chain
Drive Agility and Resilience Across Your Supply Chain
Today’s supply chains face nonstop disruption—from global tensions to climate events and labor shortages. Avoiding volatility isn’t an option,...

November Edge Report: What’s shaping freight now
November Edge Report: What’s shaping freight now
Stay informed and ready for what’s next with the November Edge Report from C.H. Robinson.
Worried About Supplier Risk? This Template Helps You Stay Ahead
Worried About Supplier Risk? This Template Helps You Stay Ahead
We all know how stressful it gets when a supplier issue catches you off guard - late delivery, a missed order, or...
Close the warehouse labor gap with overlooked talent pools
Close the warehouse labor gap with overlooked talent pools
The warehouse workforce has more than doubled between 2015 and 2025. However, the labor gap is still growing, with the U.S. deficit projected...